News & Advice

Do Older Diamonds Cost More?

Older diamonds, also known as antique or vintage diamonds, do not necessarily cost more simply because of their age. The value of a diamond, whether old or new, is determined by various factors, and age alone is not a significant determinant of price. Instead, the following factors play a more critical role in determining the cost of a diamond:

Rarity & Quality

The most crucial factor in determining a diamond’s price is its rarity and quality. Diamonds with exceptional characteristics such as large carat size, excellent color, high clarity, and a well-cut and well-proportioned shape tend to command higher prices. This applies to both old and new diamonds.

Historical Significance

Some old diamonds may have historical significance or provenance that can increase their value. For example, if a diamond has a famous previous owner or is associated with a significant historical event, it may be more valuable to collectors and enthusiasts.


Having a certificate or grading report from a reputable gemological laboratory, such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), can provide an objective assessment of a diamond’s quality and help determine its value. This is true for both old and new diamonds.

Market Demand

The price of a diamond can be influenced by current market conditions and consumer preferences. Some periods may see a higher demand for vintage or antique diamonds, which could affect their prices.

Diamond Condition

The overall condition of the diamond, including any wear and tear or damage to the stone or its setting, can impact its value. Well-preserved old diamonds may command higher prices.

Design & Craftsmanship

The design and craftsmanship of the jewelry setting in which the diamond is mounted can also affect the overall cost. Intricate and unique settings can add value to a diamond, whether old or new.

The cost of a diamond is determined by its inherent quality, rarity, historical significance, and market demand, among other factors. If you’re considering buying or selling an older diamond, have it appraised by a professional gemologist or jeweler to determine its specific value in the current market.